Italy Economic Outlook
November 20, 2018Following over three years of uninterrupted gradual growth, the economy stagnated in the third quarter, owing to muted contributions from both domestic and external demand. Survey-based indicators point to protracted economic weaknesses in the fourth quarter as tensions between the government and the European Commission (EC) escalate. On 13 November, the government returned the budget to the EC essentially unchanged after the Commission demanded spending growth was moderated and the target-deficit narrowed substantially, thus significantly increasing the likelihood that the EC will launch an infringement procedure against the country for breaching EU budgetary rules. On the previous day, Banca Carige—a mid-tier lender rooted in Italy’s northwest—approved recapitalization measures worth EUR 110 million to alleviate its heavy burden of non-performing loans, along the lines required by the ECB in order to avoid financial contagion. On a somewhat more positive note, on 26 October S&P lowered Italy’s outlook to negative but left its rating unchanged, surprising many market analysts on the upside.
Italy Economic GrowthThe recovery is expected to remain lackluster next year. Higher interest rates and erratic and interventionist government policies will likely weigh on investment decisions, while a marked slowdown in job creation and sluggish wage growth are set to restrain consumer spending growth. Complicating matters further, the risk of financial turbulence resurfacing due to the country’s high debt load and persistent problems within the banking system cloud the outlook. Met the why particular panelists project growth of 1.0% in 2019, which is down 0.1 percentage points from last month’s projection, and 0.9% in 2020.
Italy Economy Data
5 years of Italy economic forecasts for more than 30 economic indicators.
Italy Economy OverviewItaly Economic Overview
Italy is the world’s ninth biggest economy. Its economic structure relies mainly on services and manufacturing. The services sector accounts for almost three quarters of total GDP and employs around 65% of the country’s total employed people. Within the service sector, the most important contributors are the wholesale, retail sales and transportation sectors. Industry accounts for a quarter of Italy’s total production and employs around 30% of the total workforce. Manufacturing is the most important sub-sector within the industry sector. The country’s manufacturing is specialized in high-quality goods and is mainly run by small- and medium-sized enterprises. Most of them are family-owned enterprises. Agriculture contributes the remaining share of total GDP and it employs around 4.0% of the total workforce.
The country is divided into a highly-industrialized and developed northern part, where approximately 75% of the nation’s wealth is produced; and a less-developed, more agriculture-depended southern part. As a result, unemployment in the north is lower and per capita income in higher compared to the south.
Italy suffers from political instability, economic stagnation and lack of structural reforms. Prior to the 2008 financial crisis, the country was already idling in low gear. In fact, Italy grew an average of 1.2% between 2001 and 2007. The global crisis had a deteriorating effect on the already fragile Italian economy. In 2009, the economy suffered a hefty 5.5% contraction—the strongest GDP drop in decades. Since then, Italy has shown no clear trend of recovery. In fact, in 2012 and 2013 the economy recorded contractions of 2.4% and 1.8% respectively.
Going forward, the Italian economy faces a number of important challenges, one of which is unemployment. The unemployment rate has increased constantly in the last seven years. In 2013, it reached 12.5%, which is the highest level on record. The stubbornly high unemployment rate highlights the weaknesses of the Italian labor market and growing global competition. Another challenge is presented by the difficult status of the country’s public finances. In 2013, Italy was the second biggest debtor in the Eurozone and the fifth largest worldwide.
After World War II, Italy experienced a shift in its economic structure. It transformed itself from an agricultural country to one of the most industrialized economies in the world. The force behind the post-war economic miracle was the development of small- and medium-sized companies in export-related industries. In the following decades, the economy has had both ups and downs.
Being a country with very few natural resources, Italy is strongly dependent on oil imports. The economy was hit hard by the two oil crises during the 1970s. As a result, it experienced a stage of stagflation—weak economic growth combined with high unemployment and a high inflation rate. The economy began to recover in the early 1980s due to the implementation of a recovery plan. Restrictive monetary policies brought inflation down, while fiscal- and growth-oriented policies reduced public spending and tightened the budget deficit.
Before the 1980s, most of the Italian state-owned companies were a key drivers of growth. However, in the mid-1980s, the state sector started to create distortion in the economy. The mismanagement of public spending led to a deterioration of public finances and triggered excessive corruption. A round of privatization was carried out at the end of the 1980s and beginning of the 1990s. The diminishing role of the state in the economy created more space for private investment. In 1999, Italy qualified to adopt the euro and entered the European Monetary Union (EMU). The Euro was officially introduced into the economy on 1 January 2002.
Italy was hit by the financial crisis in 2007. Since then, the economy has underperformed. In a bid to face the recession, the government has passed two major austerity packages. The first one, under the administration of Silvio Berlusconi, was implemented on May 2011 and totaled EUR 24 billion. Later, in December 2011, the government led by Mario Monti introduced a EUR 30 billion austerity package. While the former package was focused on a reduction of government spending in order to reduce the nation’s budget deficit and public debt, the latter introduced, among other measures, a series of tax increases.
The incumbent government of Matteo Renzi is focusing on mitigating the effects of the financial crisis. His administration has introduced economic and structural reforms; the most important are the senate reform, labor reform and electoral law. Ensuring that the reforms that have been promised actually materialize is vital to supporting growth and strengthening Italy’s position in the global market.
Italy’s Balance of Payments
Italy has been an international debtor in most years during the past decade. Following the financial crisis in 2008, Italy, like the other periphery countries, experienced a sudden stop in private capital inflows as the level of government debt became unsustainable.
Since Italy is part of the Eurozone, it cannot rebalance its current account by adjusting the exchange rate. As a result, the country entered a system of adjustment called TARGET2. TARGET2 replaced the private capital flows with public capital flows and allowed the troubled countries to run current account deficits and avoid balance of payments crises. This gave Italy the opportunity to gradually adjust its current account balance.
The current account deficit shrank from a 3.4% deficit in 2011 to almost zero in 2012. This adjustment mainly reflects a fall in imports while exports performed quite steadily. In addition, private capital flows have increased lately, as confidence in Italian sovereign bonds has improved. However, a positive balance was not seen until 2013, when the country incurred a current account surplus of 1.0%. The main contributor to the surplus was the trade balance. In fact, in 2013, trade balance incurred a surplus three times larger than in the previous year.
Italy’s Trade Structure
Against the backdrop of a weak domestic demand, the external sector’s performance is crucial for the Italian economy. One of the most important pillars of the economy is the production of high-quality products such as in the machinery, textiles, industrial designs, alimentary and furniture sectors. These products contribute substantially to the country’s exports. However, as a country poor in national resources, its energy and manufacturing sectors are highly dependent on imports. This makes Italy’s external position vulnerable to changes in import prices such as fuel. The county recorded trade deficits from 2004 until 2011. However, in the last two years, falling imports have helped to turn the balance into positive figures.
Italy’s trade volumes increased significantly after the country joined the Eurozone. Despite growing global competition, in 2013 Italy ranked as the world’s 11th largest exporter and 11th largest importer. Italy’s main trading partners are inside the Euro area, in particular Germany, which is the country’s main exports destination and accounts for around 12.6% of Italy’s total exports and France, accounting for 11.1% of total exports. Other important export destinations are the United States, with a share of 6.9% of total exports, and Switzerland with 5.2%. Germany and France are Italy’s top imports partners, accounting for 12.4% and 11.8% share of total imports respectively.
Exports from Italy
Since the country’s manufacturing sector is specialized in high-quality goods, Italy plays an important role in the global market of luxury goods. The country’s main exports are mechanical machinery and equipment, which account for around 24% of total exports, as well as motor vehicles and luxury vehicles (7.2%). Home to some of world’s most famous fashion brands, Italy occupies a special niche in the global market of fashion and clothing. In fact, exports of clothing and footwear account for around 11.0% of the country’s total exports. Other important exports include electronic equipment (5.6%) and pharmaceutical products (4.6%).
Since 2008, the country has experienced anemic growth in merchandise exports of 1.6% annually. In nominal terms, merchandise exports have gradually outsized imports, which caused the last two years (2012 and 2013) to close with a trade balance surplus.
Imports to Italy
Italy’s main imports are fuels, which account for around 17% of total imports. This is due to the country’s lack of natural resources, which makes it highly dependent on energy imports. Other imports include machinery (14.2%), raw materials (11.0%) and food (7.0%)— Italy is a net food importer because the landscape is not suitable for developing agriculture.
Since the financial crisis, merchandise imports have expended at a slower rate on average than merchandise exports. In fact, in the last six years merchandise imports have grown a meager 0.4%.
Italy’s Economic Policy
In the past seven years, the focal point of the Italian economic policies has been to mitigate the effects of the financial crisis. Two main austerity packages have been introduced since the crisis started in 2007. Both packages aimed at reducing the country’s soaring public debt and government deficit.
Regarding structural reforms, few changes have been made over the years. The government has sought to reform public administration and public education in an attempt to improve the competitiveness of its human capital. However, the investment climate remains poor mainly due to its rigid labor laws, high labor cost, inefficient public service and the judicial system.
Italy’s new Prime Minister Matteo Renzi took office in March 2014 and promised to revive the economy by passing one reform each month in the first 110 days of his term. In a bid to boost growth, he proposed a cut in the income tax with a cost to the government of around EUR 11 billion. The PM also announced a broad labor reform that aims at changing Italy’s unemployment welfare scheme, reforming job contracts and improving job agencies. However, Renzi’s key reform was the transformation of the Senate into a non-elected chamber, putting an end to the country’s two-chamber system. The PM also pledged changes in the judiciary system, public administration and electoral law.
Italy’s Fiscal Policy
Following the crisis years, the Italian economy underwent a sizable fiscal adjustment. The country exited the EU’s Excessive Deficit Procedure in 2012, when its deficit fell to 3.0% of GDP. Italy has to keep its deficit below the threshold ceiling of 3.0% as this is one of the EU convergence criteria, also known as Maastricht criteria. The 2013 figure followed an average deficit of 4.6% that was recorded in the three preceding years. However, the primary balance has registered only one deficit since 1995, and that was in 2009. In 2012, the country reached a primary surplus of 2.5% of GDP—one of the highest surpluses in the Euro area. The high positive balance was key to improving public confidence.
Despite the fiscal adjustment, which put the fiscal balance on track, the government debt as percent of GDP has been above 110% since 1991 and has been on upward trend since 2004. In 2013, government debt stood at 132.6% of GDP, which represented the second-largest public debt among Eurozone countries and the fifth largest worldwide. Doubts about Italy’s debt sustainability triggered the downgrade of the country’s debt rating over the past three years by all three rating agencies: Standard and Poor’s, Moody’s and Fitch. Sovereign debt risk premium surged to record high levels in November 2011. However, in September 2012 it started to moderate after the European Central Bank’s (ECB) announcement of the Outright Monetary Transactions (OTM) scheme. More recently, the European Union has urged the Italian government to advance with economic and structural reforms due to the excessive macroeconomic imbalances of the country.
Italy’s Monetary Policy
At the beginning of the 1980s, the Central Bank of Italy raised its interest rate to a record high of 19.0% in order to fight the high rate of inflation. After this policy adjustment, which is seen as a “milestone” in the evolution of monetary policy in the country, the inflation rate decreased constantly. More decisive monetary policies that were conducted in the 1990s brought the inflation rate down further. In 1998, the rate fell to 1.8%.
The Central Bank of Italy is completely separated from the influences of the government and has to comply with the rules dictated by the ECB, which are the same for all the member countries of the union. The main aim of these rules is to protect the common currency.
The Bank of Italy, as part of the Eurosystem, helps to draft the monetary policy for the Euro area. The primary objective of the Eurosystem is price stability. To achieve price stability, the European Central Bank controls short-term interest rates. Changes in interest rates accommodate the financial needs of the banking system.
Lately, in June 2014, the ECB reduced the official interest rate and introduced a negative deposit rate. The impact of these monetary-policy decisions in the Italian economy is expected to be observed in the short term.
Italy’s Exchange Rate Policy
The lira was Italy’s currency from 1861 until 2002, when the country officially introduced the euro. In 1979, Italy became part of the Exchange Rate Mechanism (ERM)—a system which links the currencies of most of the European Economic Community (EEC) nations. In order to prevent big fluctuations relative to the other EEC countries, Italy had to maintain its exchange rate stable within threshold bands of +/-2.25%. However, in 1992, Italy had to devalue the Italian lira by 7.0% and as a result entered into a system where the fluctuation bands was wider.
Nowadays, the Bank of Italy, as part of the Eurosystem, participates in foreign exchange market interventions along with the ECB and the other National Central Bank of Eurozone.
The Bank conducts foreign exchange operations to keep its foreign currency reserves under control. In order to balance inflows and outflows of foreign currency without changing the composition of foreign currency reserves, the Bank of Italy buys or sells foreign currency with market counterparties.
Get a sample report showing all the data and analysis covered in our Regional, Country and Commodities reports.
|Bond Yield||3.20||-0.11 %||Nov 29|
|Exchange Rate||1.14||0.65 %||Nov 29|
|Stock Market||19,160||-0.99 %||Nov 29|
Start Your Free Trial
Start working with the reports used by the world’s major financial institutions, multinational enterprises & government agencies now. Click on the button below to get started.
Italy Economic News
December 3, 2018
The IHS Markit manufacturing Purchasing Managers’ Index (PMI) dipped to a near four-year low of 48.6 in November from October’s 49.2.
November 30, 2018
According to provisional data released by the National Statistical Institute (ISTAT) on 30 November, consumer prices dropped 0.1% month-on-month in November, following October’s flat reading.
November 30, 2018
The Italian economy contracted for the first time in nearly four years in the third quarter, weighed down by its shrinking domestic sector.
November 27, 2018
The National Institute of Statistics (Istat)’s composite business confidence indicator (Clima di Fiducia delle Imprese Italiane, IESE)—which covers the manufacturing, construction, market services and retail sectors—edged down to 111.1 points in November from October’s revised 112.5 points (previously reported: 112.6 points), marking the worst reading since December 2016. November’s reading was the result of a deterioration in sentiment in the manufacturing, construction and market services sectors, which more than offset improved sentiment in the retail trade sector.
November 27, 2018
The consumer confidence index released by the National Institute of Statistics (ISTAT) declined to 114.8 points in November from October’s revised 116.5 points (previously reported: 116.6 points). Consumers’ expectations of the future general economic situation and their assessments of the current general economic situation deteriorated, driving the downturn, likely due to growing concerns about the recent turbulence in the financial markets and the stagnation of the economy in the third quarter.